He smiled again at her, nodding. He knew that such a creative method would appeal to her, and perhaps such creativity was something that she, having chosen Nature Magic and Black Magic, would like to improve upon both in herself and others. He looked at his book and nodded. "Of course! I'll need a scribe's stand and an owl quill to inscribe the spells, so I'll do it later, ma'am!"
When she spoke about the next part of his training though, his own smile faltered a little. He had caught the vial by reflex and would have uncorked it and downed the concoction, had he not been caught up in her words. His smile was swiftly turning from cheerful to unsure, though, and then it outright vanished as she offered herself as a target. She might not have let him protest, but he just couldn't grasp the right words to express his sheer and absolute refusal of the offer. But before his mute wrestling with words turned into vague blubberings, she had gotten the message, and Madison backed down. He sighed in relief at that.
And then she made her second offer, which just sent him right back to inelegant blubbering.
"B-b-but! People are people! You can grow plants and vines over and over, but once people die, or are harmed, it's over!"
He might be able to protect them from the effects of Black Magic himself, but more so than that, it was the pain that he might inflict on them, that worried him. He looked at Madison, searching her eyes to see if this was a secret test of character or an actual and true suggestion.
And orphans! No, Manya wouldn't dare do anything to orphans, but he'd also not let anything happen to them.
"No harming children...please."
He asked this a lot more meekly. He did not delude himself into thinking that he could stop Madison if she wanted to. But he could try to convince her to not go through with it.
He had to decide, though. Three targets were there - his own teacher, prisoners, or orphans. And two of them he'd refuse out of hand. But the third...
Did anyone truly deserve to be harmed by black magic?
Of course. Otherwise, he'd not be here, trying to learn it so he could use it against the truly wicked. But what was justice but a relative scale? A criminal to him might be a hero to others...
He was looking to his teacher for guidance. His morality blinded him from a lot of harsh truths, letting him see things in a softer lie. Someone had to break it to him that not everyone is as nice.
@Madison Freebird
Last edited: May 28, 2018